I finally had a chance last night to watch Casino Royale in a theater in Paris, with the new James Bond guy, Daniel Craig. Let's say it, I did not like it, got bored, thought they had stolen the spirit of Bond.
With over 20 James Bond films seen each at least 5 times, (yeah, I know, Bondophilia will kill me), I am expressing the following comments:
The good:
* the title animation is not bad. Not great though.
* the 2nd Bond girl is gorgeous: Eva Green. and played her part as she should have
* Bond drives an Aston Martin again.
* we're back to a more human Bond. In OHMSS, Geroge Lazenby did a similar job: no extraordinary space rocket, no underwater HQ for the vilain, just a plain spy movie between superpowers. Almost no supernatural gadget.
The bad:
* I didn't like the title scene. This is not a John Woo movie, is it ?
* they are killing all the characters: no Q, no Moneypenny... M looking desperately older (I really like Dame Judi Dench). And Felix... How can he be young, old, black, white, in all the different movies ?
* this is supposed to be the first Bond movie. Craig is too old to play that part of a younger Bond. Wrong casting. They should have hired the other man, Clive Owen.
* some scenes are way too long: the running in the beginning, the romance of Bond ? It doesn't really add to the story.
* the first Bond Girl is useless, and serves no purpose. reminds me of Denise Richards (big boobs, no added value in the movie).
* the title song will not be remembered
* still some crazy error: why on earth would Bond have a defibrillator and the right medicine in his car in Montenegro ? Standard equipment makes more sense.
The ugly:
* There's no story. One bad guy has too much money, looses it, tries to regain it. Really too thin a plot. They should have tried much harder. This is probably one of the world scripts ever.
* WAY too much product placement: got it: a couple of times Nokia, even more times Sony Ericsson, a cameo appearance of Richard Branson, Virgin Atlantic, the whole Ford range: Range Rover, Jaguar, Aston Martin... Sony Vaio's a few times, Bollinger... This is not a commercial. If you have to show a brand do it, but this was over the top. Even the last scene looked like a commercial for the car, not the story.
* making Bond too human is a MISTAKE. We all remember scenes where we say to ourselves, "only 007 could do that". We laugh at the craziness of situations.
Somehow in this movie, the spirit of Bond is gone. There's no wit really (except that funny: "shaken or stirred sir ? I dont give a damn") as Samantha Bond had introduced with Pierce Brosnan (probably the best Bond with Connery). Bond is a:
* womanizer: here too, but too soft
* has lots of class: here he doesn't even have a properly tailored suit ?
* is invincible or almost (the title scene in the previous movie in North Korea was fantastic.) : not here. Showing scars and blood is OK, as long as you don't break the myth. The risk here is making him a bit like a "Die Hard" hero.
* has a very British attitude: here Craig shuts up most of the time like if he were dumb. Some say he looks like Putin...